Montserrat Llagostera
professor of Microbiology at the Autonomous University of Barcelona/UAB
AQU Catalunya's Research Assessment Committee (CAR) is responsible for the assessment and granting of accreditation for various categories of university teaching staff, as well as the recognition of merits in research. The Agency annually publishes the criteria for the various different assessment and accreditation procedures. All of this, together with the framework of well-defined review procedures, serves as the context for the work of the members of the Research Assessment Committee's various specific committees.
With regard to the committee that deals specifically with Life Sciences, each application is assessed by two people from the same or a closely related subject area. This is followed by a consensual face-to-face assessment of each application by the Research Assessment Committee, taking into account the two aforementioned assessments. I would here underline that the reviewers' opinions regarding assessment are given totally independently, the criteria are responsibly and rigorously applied, with both the applicant's background and the finer details stemming from the actual assessment being taken into account. These same values govern the meetings of the Research Assessment Committee that, during the time I have been a member, has made all of its decisions on the basis of consensus, which at times has led to very intense in-depth discussions.